Bedminster Reformed Church

The Bedminster Reformed Church was organized in 1758 and built three churches during its history. The second (photo left) was a wooden structure built in 1818. It stood facing south in the old cemetery on Route 202-206. After a new church was built on Main Street in Bedminster village in 1897 (currently Grace Chapel), the old church was sold. The structure was destroyed in a windstorm in 1898 before it could be moved.

Andrew D. Mellick, in his classic The Story of an Old Farm (1889), describes attending this church as a youngster in the 1850s:

“At the next turn in the road we are suddenly confronted by the venerable church of Bedminster…. It is an oblong wooden structure painted white, with green blinds covering its double rows of square capped windows, and with an octagonal tower which supports a round-topped cupola.”

Mellick’s full description can be read on pages 5-8 of The Story of an Old Farm:


  1. I grew up in the Bedminster Reformed Church on Main St. My parents attended there until the late 1980’s I believe. The first pastor I remember was Bob Marsh. His daughter, Laurie, was about my age and my mom used to say we were inseparable friends when we were in Nursery school. I’d love to contact her if she ever reads this. 🙂 I also remember George Crumley being the pastor there when I was in elementary school.

    My mother, Irene B. Dobbs, founded the Crossroads Nursery School when she got tired of driving me to Basking Ridge to nursery school. They used the education wing in the back for classroom space and there was a playground across the driveway, behind the manse. It ran for more than 30 years. She used to call it a ministry to the “up and out” kids of the area. Their parents had money but not much time for little ones.

    My dad, Harold J. Dobbs, was the contractor for the education wing on the back of the church, I’m not sure what year but I don’t remember it ever NOT being there. Probably built in the early to mid 1950’s?

    My dad told me that they built an “in floor heating” system in the downstairs, there are copper pipes buried in the concrete. Eventually those corroded and began to leak up out of the floor, so they abandoned the piping and resorted to other means to heat the space.

    My sister, Janice D. Pedersen, was married there in the early 1960’s. Somewhere I have home movies of all that. My brother, Stephen B. Dobbs, was the cameraman as I remember.

    Lots of memories tied up in Bedminster and this church. Thanks for posting a bit of the history.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Become a Member of THSSH

Subscribe to THSSH Blog

Sign up to receive updates via email.*

Upcoming Events

1770s Festival

October 6, 2024

Latest Comments

  1. The 1889 edition is can also be downloaded from the Internet Archive and from Google Books. The Bernardsville Library local…

  2. Roy such an interesting article. I didn't know anything about Stonemere. Many of the mansions on the Bernards Mountain had…

  3. Too bad it happened well before the bicentennial. It might have been saved 6 or 8 years later!

  4. My family lived in the Old Pottersville Hotel in the late 60’s before Southfield Drive was built. Large pieces of…