Hartfeld House

Matheny School on Burnt Mills Road. Clarence Dillon Public Library. RUcore:

During the 1930s and 40s, Burnt Mills in Bedminster boasted a summer hotel, the Hartfeld House, run by Solomon Hartfeld / Hartfield (1866-1947) and his son Isadore (1890-1976), Jewish immigrants from Austria.  The hotel was built on the old Paulison farm along the North Branch of the Raritan River, above the current Burnt Mills Road bridge.

Hartfeld House made headlines in 1931 when an unidentified worker, who had been recently hired, was found dead there from alcoholism.  

Hartfeld House foundations, 1956. Courtesy Click to enlarge.

The hotel closed in the 1940s but became the first home of the Matheny School in 1946. The school moved to Far Hills in 1949 and then to Peapack. 

The old hotel was subsequently torn down and by 1956, only the foundations were visible.  Burnt Mills nursery later operated on the site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Become a Member of THSSH

Subscribe to THSSH Blog

Sign up to receive updates via email.*

Upcoming Events

1770s Festival

October 6, 2024

Latest Comments

  1. My family lived in the Old Pottersville Hotel in the late 60’s before Southfield Drive was built. Large pieces of…

  2. My mother’s family went way back in Peapack-Gladstone. When my uncle T Leonard Hill built a swimming pool behind his…

  3. There is a resident of Gladstone that built a scale model of the bridge that went through Gladstone. It should…

  4. My family and I lived in West Oak St. for 32 years and never knew any of this . Thank…

  5. Hi Dan, Haven't traced it back further than that 1873 map, but it definitely looks earlier.